Secureframe, Vanta, and Scrut are three prominent players offering robust compliance management solutions.
Each platform has unique strengths: Secureframe offers simplicity and ease of compliance management, while Vanta offers an extensive range of integrations to support multiple enterprise-level compliance requirements. The Scrut platform offers robust customizations, proactive implementation support, comprehensive dashboards, and other features to simplify compliance management for businesses of all sizes and across all industries.
This comparison will examine each platform’s core features and benefits across critical categories. By evaluating these tools, you’ll gain insights into which best meets your business’s compliance requirements. Whether you prioritize ease of use, risk management, or customization, this analysis will guide you in making an informed decision. Let’s understand how these platforms compare and which is right for you.
Introduction to Secureframe, Vanta, and Scrut
Secureframe
Secureframe offers a compliance management platform that helps organizations ensure adherence to compliance quickly. The tool offers formidable features such as pre-built frameworks, control monitoring, risk management, vendor risk management, and more. Secureframe’s support for multiple compliance frameworks makes it popular among businesses as it helps them comply with multiple regulations without depending on multiple vendors.
Vanta
Vants offers various compliance management features, including support for major compliance frameworks and automated offerings. We will see how Vanta’s platform simplifies compliance management for organizations that don’t face budget constraints.
Scrut
Scrut offers an all-in-one governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) platform that provides customizable scalable, effortless, and cost-optimized compliance management for startups, mid-sized organizations, and high-growth teams. The platform supports 50+ out-of-the-box compliance frameworks, and custom notes for simplified compliance management. Moreover, it also helps businesses easily integrate with popular cloud services, CRM tools, database platforms, and more.
Key considerations when choosing a compliance platform
The primary factor when choosing a compliance platform is its adaptability. It must effectively accommodate compliance regulations, organization-specific policies, varying user requirements, and risk management expectations.
As we compare Secureframe, Vanta, and Scrut, here are some key considerations to keep in mind:
- Simplified compliance management: Managing multiple regulatory requirements can be complex and highly error-prone. The right platform automates processes and proactively manages regulatory requirements, preventing compliance debt that can hinder business growth.
- Support for multiple frameworks: The more diverse your business operations, the more complex your compliance obligations. Investing in a compliance platform that supports a broad range of frameworks ensures you don’t have to juggle multiple solutions to stay compliant.
- Ease of integration: The compliance management platform must integrate smoothly with your existing tech stack. It should also be able to connect seamlessly with your ERP systems, cloud services, security tools, human resource processes, and more. A lack of integration can create silos and require additional resources to make the platform work within your ecosystem.
- Customer support: Highly proactive and responsive customer support is essential for the compliance platform to help customers against compliance issues at any time. Delays otherwise in addressing such issues can lead to legal penalties and reputational damage. A reliable compliance platform should offer responsive customer support with well-defined points of contact to assist with integration failures, regulatory clarifications, and troubleshooting.
- Customization: An effective compliance management platform cannot limit itself to rigid policies and pre-built templates. Customization is essential to helping businesses adhere to compliance requirements in ways that make sense to them. Tools like Scrut offer deeper customization at no extra cost to help simplify compliance management for their customers.
- Built for scaling: Whether expanding into new markets or tackling new compliance frameworks, the platform must adapt without hassles.
Supported frameworks: How Secureframe, Vanta, and Scrut compare
A compliance platform that supports a broader range of frameworks, including customizations, reduces the risk of unidentified violations. Additionally, the support for these frameworks would make sense only if they are readily available without additional costs. There are platforms like Vanta that charge based on per-framework pricing, which makes it difficult to businesses to use them as they scale up. Here are the frameworks supported by the three platforms with or without additional charges:
| Secureframe | Vanta | Scrut |
| Multiple frameworks, including SOC 2, ISO 27001/ISO 27701, GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS, NIST frameworks CMMC 2.0, MVSP, and more | Multiple frameworks, including ISO 27001:2022/27017/ 27018, PCI DSS, GDPR, Microsoft SSPA, and a few customized frameworks at a higher price. | 50+ out-of-box compliance frameworks, including SOC 2, GDPR, ISO 27001, PCI DSS, CCPA, CIS Critical Security Controls, HIPAA,Microsoft SSPA, FERPA, COPPA, NIST CSF, CSA CCM, FedRAMP, ISO 27017, NIST AI RMF, SOX, ISO 22301, ISO 27018, CMMC, NIST 800-53, NIST 800-171, and custom frameworks and local regulations |
Key features: Vanta vs Secureframe vs Scrut
With support for various compliance frameworks, the three tools offer unique features to best meet various organizations’ compliance needs and business constraints. Here are these features:
Secureframe
- Support for 35+ frameworks.
- Customizable frameworks available (for a higher price).
- White glove customer support as per specific time zones
- Cookie-cutter modules.
Vanta
- Support for nearly 27 frameworks.
- Dashboard for displaying compliance progress and risk heatmaps.
- Automated vendor discovery (available at a higher price).
- Audit by frameworks.
Scrut
- One-stop solution to compliance management: Scrut streamlines compliance with 50+ built-in and custom frameworks, 90+ expert-vetted policy templates, and 1400+ unified controls, automating key workflows through seamless integrations with leading tools and applications.
- White-glove compliance support: Scrut offers expert guidance at every step of your compliance journey so you don’t have to navigate the complex standards alone. From onboarding, documentation, and control mapping to customization, audit preparation, and certification, the platform empowers companies to have hands-on expertise in compliance management.
- Reliable risk measurement: Scrut allows you to quantify your risk profile using expert-vetted scoring methodologies. It calculates inherent and residual risk scores, helping you assess the effectiveness of risk treatment plans and address critical vulnerabilities.
- Automated evidence collection: Scrut offers seamless evidence gathering for speedy certifications and audits. It easily integrates with cloud providers, SaaS applications, DevOps tools, HR systems, and more to ensure uninterrupted control monitoring. The automated evidence collection is done as per employee lists from HR systems, security settings for vulnerability scans, Jira tickets, and more. This saves hours of manual work and offers more accurate data when required.
- Actionable dashboards: Scrut’s intuitive dashboards offer consolidated compliance and security posture with real-risk reporting on risk metrics, drill-down view, consistent updates on framework status, vendor compliance info, and more. With all the security alerts in one place, the platform makes it easier to identify jobs to be done and prioritize critical compliance.
- Continuous monitoring: Scrut’s continuous monitoring allows you to automatically scan cloud infrastructure against 230+ CIS Benchmarks across all popular cloud vendors. The platform ensures, every 24 hours, a scanning of cloud configurations and vulnerabilities across critical controls. With Scrut you can ensure that controls like encryption enforcements, access reviews and more remain compliant and effective.
- Deeper customization at no extra cost: Many compliance platforms charge an additional fee for custom workflows, additional control mapping, creating new controls, and customizing controls based on security policies. With Scrut, you can customize workflows and controls at no extra cost.
- Customizable multi-approval reviews: As part of the custom workflows you can build with Scrut, you can add a multi-approval process for multiple stakeholders to review and approve compliance artifacts, ensuring thorough assessment.
- Risk identification: Scrut offers end-to-end risk management for your codebase, infrastructure, applications, vendors, employees, access points, and more. It ensures that multi-approval is implemented for these workloads in order to restrict any potential compliance violations. Once identified, Scrut auto-populates mitigation tasks with relevant controls, streamlining risk management.
- Effortless vendor management: Scrut’s Vendor management solutions comes with a dedicated vendor portal for easy onboarding, questionnaire-based assessments, and more. The aim is to ensure the identification and mitigation of third-party risks so that businesses can leverage the benefits of vendor services without any compliance threats.
Audit and evidence collection: A feature breakdown
Secureframe
Secureframe offers an automated approach to consolidating evidence data into a single repository to ensure audit readiness. Organizations can rely on Secureframe for efficient evidence collection and a faster certification process. However, as the volume of audit data and evidence collection increases, the platform may experience unexpected response delays due to scalability limitations.
Vanta
Vanta offers features like audit center to enable faster evidence collection, audits, and certification. While users appreciate its features for reducing audit stress, there has been confusion regarding pricing models, audit timelines, and other aspects. With customer support limited to specific time zones, Vanta often leaves users without assistance during—causing more panic than resolution.
Scrut
The Audit Center centralizes all audit activities, streamlining compliance across frameworks like SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR, HIPAA, and PCI DSS. Users can invite auditors directly, enabling seamless collaboration, artifact sharing, and real-time task tracking. Scrut automates documentation collection, reducing manual effort and errors while systematically gathering all required evidence. The platform supports simultaneous audits, allowing users to define scopes, assign responsibilities, and generate reports within a single platform for stronger internal controls and compliance.
Continuous control monitoring: Vanta vs Secureframe vs Scrut
Secureframe
Secureframe offers all the major features for control monitoring including automated tracking, a centralized dashboard, pre-built policies, and more. However, its list of integrations is limited compared to the other two platforms in this list. Moreover, many automation features are not available in their basic feature making it difficult for businesses planning to scale up.
Vanta
Vanta also offers continuous monitoring as one of its features where it helps users enforce necessary practices for compliance management and risk assessment. Unlike Secureframe, its list of integrations is growing and it has more flexible features for compliance monitoring. However, the downside here is the high-pricing and limited support for certain vendors. For instance, there have been complaints against Vanta offering better monitoring with CloudWatch rather than Datadog.
Scrut
Scrut offers “always-on” control monitoring through its automated GRC platform, helping security teams manage and validate controls in real time. It simplifies monitoring by offering automation features, post-certification monitoring, real-time alerts, and more. Unlike the other two, its automation and integration features are uniformly available and effective without additional charges. This makes it a great choice for growing businesses.
Risk assessment: evaluating each platform’s strengths
Secureframe
Secureframe offers AI-driven features for continuous risk assessment for both internal and vendor-related risks. It offers features to generate risk scores and treatment plans instantly and offers comprehensive visualization through the dashboard.
Vanta
Vanta’s platform includes a built-in module for risk assessment that allows security teams to score risk status within a pre-defined matrix. This helps organizations gain more specific insights into potential compliance risks, which can be addressed accordingly. While the platform supports automation for risk assessment, there are factors that limit its utility, including customization features behind paywall, limited risk impact mapping, gated pricing for many risk management features and more.
Scrut
Scrut provides a customizable risk assessment tool that enables organizations to identify, quantify, and mitigate risks across their internal systems and vendor ecosystem. The platform offers continuous automated tests and monitoring across 1400+ controls and real-time risk monitoring to allow security teams to detect and address compliance vulnerabilities and risks as they arise. The platform enables continuous monitoring of risks across various aspects of the organization’s ecosystem, such as code bases, infrastructure, applications, vendors, and employees.
Scrut’s dynamic risk register allows users to either choose from a pre-built risk library or create custom risks, making it adaptable to different business environments. Scrut utilizes built-in, expert-vetted scoring methodologies to assess both inherent and residual risk scores. This quantification allows organizations to understand their risk exposure, prioritize significant risks, and develop effective mitigation strategies. Security teams can also assign risk scores based on impact and likelihood, prioritizing critical risks for mitigation. The platform offers automated workflows for developing risk treatment plans, allowing organizations to choose appropriate actions such as accepting, mitigating, transferring, or avoiding each identified risk. The platform also offers automated risk tracking, custom risk formulas, and custom risk scoring to ensure business-oriented risk management.
Additionally, Scrut maps risks directly to security controls across major compliance frameworks, including ISO 27001, SOC 2, and HIPAA. This helps teams understand which controls address specific risks, improving remediation planning.
Integration capabilities: how they support your existing systems
Secureframe
Secureframe offers simplified integration with many applications, including cloud platforms, CRM and ERP tools, security tools, and more. This helps organizations ensure deeper compliance management throughout their digital ecosystems. A major issue for the platform is its lack of integration support for containerization and IaC tools like Docker, Kubernetes, Terraform, and more. Users have also pointed out that as the number of integrated tools or applications increases, the platform becomes more reliant on manual efforts.
Vanta
Vanta also supports integrations with various tools, including popular cloud vendors and database management tools. While these integrations extend the platform’s features for compliance management, they are primarily available at higher prices and, therefore, are difficult for businesses that are scaling up.
Scrut
Scrut’s GRC platform is designed to provide scalable compliance management features while ensuring seamless integration with various third-party tools and platforms. The platform offers automated and customizable features for real-time risk management and compliance monitoring that can scale up complex assets like cloud environments, HRMS platforms, database management systems, and more. Scrut ensures continuous security compliance while supporting multiple deep integrations for tools and applications of varying complexity across different use cases. Some of its integrations include AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, AWS Identity Center, and Microsoft Defender. Scrut can help customize or add new integrations to support your tech stack.
Customer support and onboarding
Secureframe
While user feedback mentions a lack of clarity in features like security training and device management, Secureframe generally receives positive reviews for its customer support. The onboarding support can be more structured, and users can use a more hands-on approach and prompt response.
Vanta
Vanta often receives feedback regarding insufficient control descriptions, clarity in reporting features, and other concerns. Since many features require higher-tier subscriptions, there is room for improvement in its customer experience. The users seek prompt responses from customer support as there are complaints about vague control descriptions, additional prices for better features, limited guidance during onboarding and more.
Scrut
Scrut’s 24/7 customer support has earned it a rating of 4.9/5 on popular platforms like G2. The company provides monthly and quarterly reviews to help businesses ensure uncompromised compliance. Scrut also provides smooth onboarding and technical support along the way. While some customer feedback points to certain updates or a learning curve, the overall support experience is highly rated, with special mentions of its user-friendly interface and quick resolutions.
Final thoughts: Secureframe vs Vanta vs Scrut
We conducted an in-depth comparative study of Vanta, Secureframe, and Scrut, covering the various features that business leaders should consider when selecting a compliance management platform for their enterprise or growing business.
Based on this comparison, you can choose the best platform to help you comply with various frameworks and regulations designed to protect your digital assets from the latest threats.
But if your priority is to have a comprehensive compliance and risk management platform that goes beyond audit readiness—offering continuous monitoring, real-time risk alerts, policy automation, and unified security governance—Scrut is the better fit.
Beyond its features, Scrut stands out for its highly responsive customer support and strong pricing, ensuring businesses not only achieve compliance but also improve overall security resilience. For organizations looking for a scalable, automation-first compliance solution that aligns with risk management, Scrut Automation is a future-proof choice.
Ready to take the next step? Explore Scrut’s all-in-one GRC platform today.
FAQs
How much does Vanta cost compared to Secureframe?
Compared to Secureframe, Vanta offers a range of pricing models with most desirable features limited to higher-end subscriptions. On the other hand, Scrut offers an all-features-inclusive platform for better compliance management than both Vanta and Secureframe.
Which platform is the best fit for growing businesses?
Growing businesses need a compliance management platform that can easily scale with them as they expand without straining their budget. Scrut is the perfect platform for this purpose, supporting 50+ out-of-the-box compliance frameworks, 90+ policy templates, 1,000+ controls, and a large number of integrations. The platform also offers scalable, customizable, automated compliance features to ensure uninterrupted regulatory adherence for growing businesses.
How does Scrut differentiate itself from Vanta and Secureframe?
Unlike Secureframe and Vanta, Scrut helps streamline compliance workflows with its intuitive interface and automated evidence collection simplify audit preparation and reduce manual effort, making it ideal for organizations prioritizing efficiency and scalability.
